You say you want a revolution?

March 2, 2010 at 1:19 pm | Posted in Historical, Judiciary, politics straight up | Leave a comment
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Concentrated wealth on increase. Washington D.C. Concentration of wealth in the control of a few corporations has increased since 1931. Dr. Charles A. Beard, (right) told the Senate Judiciary subcommittee today. Dr. Beard, noted political scientist and economist, was testifying in defense of the O'Mahoney Corporation Licensing Bill, which, if passed, will require corporations dealing in interstate commerce to comply with specified standards to aqcuire a federal license. Senator Joseph O'Mahoney, author of the bill and Chairman of the Committee, is on the left. 1937 January 27. (Library of Congress)

To Beard, the Constitution was a counter-revolution, set up by rich bond holders (bonds were “personal property”), in opposition to the farmers and planters (land was “real property.”) The Constitution, Beard argued, was designed to reverse the radical democratic tendencies unleashed by the Revolution among the common people, especially farmers and debtors (people who owed money to the rich). In 1800, said Beard, the farmers and debtors, led by plantation slaveowners, overthrew the capitalists and established Jeffersonian democracy.

Other historians supported the class-conflict interpretation noting the states confiscated great semifeudal landholdings of Loyalists and gave them out in small parcels to ordinary farmers. Conservatives such as William Howard Taft were shocked at the Progressive interpretation because it seem to belittle the Constitution. History professors, however, mostly adopted it and by 1930 it became the standard interpretation of the era among them, but was largely ignored by the legal community.

Beginning about 1950 revisionist historians argued that the progressive interpretation was factually incorrect.

[snip]

The Progressive interpretation of the era was largely replaced by the intellectual history approach that stressed the power of ideas, especially republicanism in stimulating the Revolution.

I would certainly agree that the country’s founders were motivated by ideals of liberty and individual rights, but that does not preclude motivations of economic bias.

A California study in 1969 revealed that the death penalty was imposed in only 4.8% of murder cases with “white collar” defendants but was imposed in 42% of cases that had “blue collar” defendants.

It’s hard to get away from the fact that there is an inherent belief that money equals virtue.

Advertisements

Chilcot Hearings on Iraq War

January 29, 2010 at 10:39 pm | Posted in Bush, Foreign Affairs, Historical, terrorism, torture | Leave a comment
Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Ctesiphon, the imperial capital of the Arsacids and of the Sassanids, was one of the great cities of ancient Mesopotamia, now Iraq. c1932 (Library of Congress)

Wufnik at Scholars and Rogues has been doing regular posts on the goings on at the Chilcot hearings on the Iraq war that are well worth a read.

The first post in which Wufnik talks about the inquiry is Christmas music (9)–Best English folk/indie/whatever Christmas album, then Stout Denial, More Chilcot, Blogging Blair and Blogging Blair (2).

The British Government has a website for the Iraq Inquiry that has video, transcripts and background documents.

History Repeats Itself.

May 24, 2009 at 11:58 am | Posted in Historical | Leave a comment
Tags: , , , , ,
On the alphabetical front   1934 Dec.  Daniel Robert Fitzpatrick, artist (1891-1969)

"On the alphabetical front" 1934 Dec. Daniel Robert Fitzpatrick, artist (1891-1969)

(Library of Congress) Cartoon shows the Democratic donkey clutching a group of alphabetical signs for the New Deal agencies — P.W.A., N.R.A., C.C.C., T.V.A., A.A.A., and R.F.C. In contrast, the GOP elephant holds only one sign giving the international distress signal — S.O.S. Appears to compare the complex Democratic program in progress to deal with the Depression with the lack of constructive action on the part of the Republicans.

About the artist, Daniel Robert Fitzpatrick:

Fitzpatrick was a supporter of women’s suffrage and the trade union movement and during the 1930s led the attack against the mergence of fascism in Europe. One critic, Stephen Hess, has argued that Fitzpatrick played a significant role in changing American public opinion on Nazi Germany: “Daniel Fitzpatrick, one of the masters in the use of symbolism, transformed Nazi Germany’s swastika into a horrific death machine. As Adolf Hitler’s armies marched across Europe in the 1930s, Fitzpatrick used his symbol repeatedly to challenge America to rethink their isolationist stand and enter World War II.”

Fitzpatrick twice won the Pulitzer Prize for cartooning: The Laws of Moses and the Laws of Today (1926), and How Would Another Mistake Help? (1955). He retired in 1958 and was replaced on the St. Louis Post-Dispatch by another radical cartoonist, Bill Mauldin. Daniel Robert Fitzpatrick died in 1969.

As a country we are repeatedly turning the same damned corner. The path may be well worn, it may be familiar, but it inevitably leads to the same failed results. This is why education is so important, particularly history education.

Know Your Labor Leaders: Martin Irons

April 10, 2009 at 5:05 pm | Posted in Historical, Labor | Leave a comment
Tags: , , , , , , ,
Martin Irons, of St. Louis, Chairman Executive Committee of the Knights of Labor, District No. 101 / photographed by R.G. Gardner, Kansas City, Missouri.  Illus. in: Harpers weekly, v. 30, no. 1529 (1886 April 10)

Martin Irons, of St. Louis, Chairman Executive Committee of the Knights of Labor, District No. 101 / photographed by R.G. Gardner, Kansas City, Missouri. Illus. in: Harper's weekly, v. 30, no. 1529 (1886 April 10)

It was in 1886 that Martin Irons, as chairman of the executive board of the Knights of Labor of the Gould southwest railway system, defied capitalist tyranny, and from that hour he was doomed. All the powers of capitalism combined to crush him, and when at last he succumbed to overwhelming odds, he was hounded from place to place until he was ragged and foot-sore and the pangs of hunger gnawed at his vitals.

Eugene V. Debs, December 9, 1900

Train magnate Jay Gould made himself famous for all American labor historians by saying, “I can hire half the working class to kill the other half.”

He proved his malicious intent by hiring gunmen to murder railroad workers during the Great Southwest Railroad Strike of 1886. The original call for the strike occurred in Sherman, Texas at a Knights of Labor meeting. Gould had been defeated by the union in 1885, but he triumphed in 1886.

Jay Gould (between 1865 and 1892)

Jay Gould (between 1865 and 1892)

Both strikes were led by Texas labor hero Martin Irons. After the big defeat, Irons was blacklisted from his trade as a railroad machinist.

The differences that have arisen between Jay Gould and the men who control the East Tennessee, Virginia and Georgia Railroad system have given rice [sic] to negotiations which, it is thought, will soon put Mr. Gould in control of the Louisville and Nashville Road and the Central Railroad of Georgia.

NY Times, September 13, 1883

The great railway strike--attempt to start a freight train, under a guard of United States marshals, at East St. Louis, Illinois / from a sketch by G. J. Nebinger.  1886

The great railway strike--attempt to start a freight train, under a guard of United States marshals, at East St. Louis, Illinois / from a sketch by G. J. Nebinger. 1886

The central figure in the great railroad strike on the Gould Southwestern system was Martin Irons. To those who know anything of the man this circumstance proves conclusively that the strike was not inaugurated at the request of the best element in the Knights of Labor of the Southwest, but at the demand of the worst characters in the order.

NY Times, May 10, 1886

Martin Irons, the leader of the Knights of Labor strike on the Missouri Pacific Railroad last Spring, was arrested in Kansas City last night, and will be brought to this city [St. Louis, MO] to answer to the charge found against him in the indictment for complicity in tapping the private telegraph wires running into Vice-President Hozie’s residence.

NY Times, September 21, 1886

Terrence Vincent Powderly (wood engraving, 1886)

Terrence Vincent Powderly (wood engraving, 1886)

The story of the Great Southwest strike, a textbook example of the upheavals of 1886, has long been told as an epic battle between railway millionaire Jay Gould, national Knights of Labor head Terence Powderly, and Martin Irons, with many historians and contemporaries casting strike leader Irons as the epitome of impatient, romantic, and even deluded labor activism. District Assembly 101’s call to walk out on Gould’s southwestern system of roads was, arguably, strategically ill-advised. It vastly overestimated the Knights’ power in the wake of two victories against Gould in 1885 and certainly ignored the district’s lack of funds, lax support among skilled trainmen, and the terms of an historic agreement between the national Knights and Gould. A closer look at Irons’s life and leadership, however, reveals a more complicated explanation of the strike and takes into fuller account the experiences and perceptions of striking railroaders. This essay holds that events on the ground, combined with the heady context of the Great Upheaval, influenced Irons and his supporters’ decisions to strike, to expand the effort, and to defend it with violence. The ensuing attacks on Irons stemmed partly from his unstable personal history but largely from the broader social anxieties that the conflict had exposed.

— “Blaming Martin Irons: Leadership and Popular Protest in the 1886 Southwest Strike,” an essay by Theresa A. Case, Journal Of The Gilded Age And Progressive Era, Volume 8, Number 1, January 2009

The first dynamite bomb thrown in America May 4th, 1886. The personnel of the great anarchist trial at Chicago. Begun Monday June 21st 1886. Ended Friday, August 20th 1886.  Copyrighted by M. Umbdenstock & Co., Chicago, 1886.  I have examined all the pictures on this sheet and hereby certify that they are all correct copies of photographs of the persons named. Police Captain. Michael J. Schaack-- lower left.

"The first dynamite bomb thrown in America" May 4th, 1886. The personnel of the great anarchist trial at Chicago. Begun Monday June 21st 1886. Ended Friday, August 20th 1886. Copyrighted by M. Umbdenstock & Co., Chicago, 1886. "I have examined all the pictures on this sheet and hereby certify that they are all correct copies of photographs of the persons named. Police Captain. Michael J. Schaack"-- lower left.

“Failure of the Great Southwest Strike represented the first major defeat sustained by the Knights of Labor and proved to be a fatal blow to their vision of an industrial union that would unite all railroad workers in the Southwest into ‘one big union.’ Once again, an emerging labor organization was crushed when competing with powerful, determined and well-organized industrialists in command of nationally based corporations,” Allen concludes.

Martin Irons was blacklisted and could not hold a regular job. He moved to St. Louis, Little Rock, Ark., and Fort Worth for brief periods, sometimes using an assumed name.
In 1894, his health was failing; G.B. Harris of Bruceville, a democratic socialist, offered him a home. Allen reports that he continued to work for social reform until his death in 1900.

Molly Ivins, Fort Worth Star-Telegram, 2000

The Missouri State Federation of Labor gathered funds for a monument to mark the grave. In 1911, with the Texas State Federation of Labor officially in attendance, the monument was unveiled.

Dependent Parents, R.L. Witt. He is apparently working on the railroad, but his three oldest children, here work in the Roanoke (Va.) Cotton Mills. Mamie is only 12 years old and earns very little. Home is very poorly kept. Mother would not be in the photo. Location: Roanoke, Virginia.  1911 May.  (Photo: Lewis Wickes Hine)

Dependent Parents, R.L. Witt. He is apparently working on the railroad, but his three oldest children, here work in the Roanoke (Va.) Cotton Mills. Mamie is only 12 years old and earns very little. Home is very poorly kept. Mother would not be in the photo. Location: Roanoke, Virginia. 1911 May. (Photo: Lewis Wickes Hine)

The Texas State Historical Association has much interesting information about the Texas State Federation of Labor.

Blog at WordPress.com.
Entries and comments feeds.